Target offers the KitchenAid 4-Slice Toaster in Silver, model no. KMT4115, for an in-cart price of $55.99. Click through this link to drop it to $50.99. (You may need to click the link before adding this item to cart to get the discount.) With free shipping, that's the lowest total price we could find by $18 (outside of the price below). It features extra-wide 1.5" slots and five shade settings.

A close price, Home Depot and Amazon offer it in Black/Silver for $51.49 with free shipping.