Amazon offers the Neutrogena Oil-Free Moisture Cream 4-oz. Bottle in Sensitive Skin for $5.39. Check out via Subscribe & Save to drop it to $5.12. With free shipping, that's about $5 under what you'd pay at a local store. It features a water-based non-greasy formula.
Be sure to cancel your subscription after receiving your item to avoid being billed for subsequent shipments.
Of note, Target offers it for the same price via subscription.