Sears offers the Proctor Silex Modern Toaster Oven, model no. 31122, for $19.99. Choose in-store pickup to avoid the $7.25 shipping charge. That's at least $7 less than you'd pay at another local retail store, although most merchants charge at least $35. It features a 30-minute timer with auto shut-off.
Of note, Shop Your Way Rewards members will earn a Sears credit with this purchase and may be eligible for additional credits and discounts. Plus, Shop Your Way Max members are eligible for free shipping.