A best bet is the Stuhrling Original Men's Automatic Watch (pictured), model no. 229A2.33166, for $75 before the coupon code mentioned above, $67.50 after. With
$4.95 for shipping, it's the lowest total price we could find by $43. Features include a surgical-grade stainless steel case, self-winding automatic movement, subdial, rubber strap, and water resistance up to 165 feet.
Update 2: It's now available with free shipping.