Amazon offers the Whiskas Temptations Mixups Cat Treats 6.3-oz. Bag in Backyard Cookout or Surfers' Delight for $3.19. (While the image shows multiples, this is the price for one bag.) Clip the $1 off coupon on the product page, then order via Subscribe & Save to make it $2.03. With free shipping, that's $4 below the best shipped price we could find for a smaller 3-oz. bag. Sales tax is added where applicable.

Be sure to cancel Subscribe & Save once your order ships to avoid being billed for subsequent shipments. Also, the $1 off coupon is only valid once per account.