Walmart offers the Wilton Heart Donut Bake Pan, model no. 21050632, for $6.67. Choose in-store pickup to dodge the $4.97 shipping fee. (Amazon charges the same with free shipping for Prime members.) That's the lowest total price we could find by $4. This dishwasher-safe pan makes six heart-shaped donuts.

Not in love? Also available is the the Wilton Standard Dounut Pan, model no. 21050565, for $6.79. (Once again, Amazon charges the same with free shipping for Prime members.) That's $2 under the lowest total price we could find elsewhere. It makes six standard-shaped donuts.