Cole Haan offers the Cole Haan Men's Topsail Penny Loafers in Black or Brown for $102. Coupon code "XCHANGE16" drops them to $76.50. With $5 for shipping, that's $94 off list and the lowest price we could find. They're available in sizes 7 to 11.5 13.
Amazon cuts up to 35% off a selection of Allen Edmonds men's shoes. (Prices are as marked.) Plus, all orders qualify for free shipping. A couple of best bets, with prices compared to non-price-matching merchants: