Amazon takes $2 off a selection of Maybelline New York mascara via this clippable coupon. Plus, take $1 off Maybelline New York pencils via this clippable coupon. Even better, cut an extra 5% off and bag free shipping when you add these items to cart via Subscribe & Save. Combined, that puts many items about $2 under what you could expect to pay in local stores.

Be sure to cancel Subscribe & Save after your order ships to avoid being charged for subsequent orders.