Best Buy via eBay offers the Insignia 2-Slice Toaster in Black, model no. NS-TS2SBK6, for $9.99. Opt for in-store pickup to avoid the $8.96 shipping charge. That's $10 off list and the lowest price we could find. It features a cool-touch exterior and cord storage.
(Note that if you opt to ship this, you'll get a lower shipping price via Best Buy direct.)