For in-store pickup only, and with availability limited by ZIP code, Sears offers the Pelican Afterglow AW.2 Nunchuck Controller for Nintendo Wii, model no. PL-7603, for $2.42. That's $11 under the best via-pickup price we could find elsewhere. It features a clear plastic housing that can be illuminated by red, blue, or green LED light.

Of note, Shop Your Way Rewards members will earn a Sears credit with this purchase and may be eligible for additional credits and discounts. Orders placed by December 22 at 3 pm ET are guaranteed to arrive by Christmas.