Sears offers the Hamilton Beach Retractable Cord 2-Slice Toaster in Black/Chrome, model no. 22810, for $17.99. Plus, Shop Your Way Rewards members bag a $10.18 SYWR credit. Opt for in-store pickup to avoid the $7.75 shipping fee. Assuming you'll spend the credit, that's the lowest price we could find by $15. It features oversized slots that can accommodate bagels, and it automatically keeps your toast warm until you're ready to cover it with an unhealthy amount of Nutella.
Of note, Shop Your Way Rewards members will earn a Sears credit with this purchase and may be eligible for additional credits and discounts.